Anxious At Bedtime

Ever find yourself tossing and turning at night, wondering if there’s something lurking in the shadows? Make that problem worse with Anxious At Bedtime!

Imagine a haunted sleepover with your funniest friends, that’s Anxious At Bedtime. Monica and Cash dig into true ghost stories, eerie history, and paranormal weirdness, mixing scares with sarcasm, jump scares with jokes, and always reminding you: even though the world can be a scary place, we’re probably fine.

Episodes

May 14, 2026

26 min

This week we're diving into listener stories featuring phantom pets, aggressive spirits, and the kind of paranormal chaos that makes you reconsider every moment you ever thought you were alone in a restroom.
We'll hear about a possible ghost cat lurking around, a shadowy figure that may have physically thrown an object hard enough to injure someone, and a terrifying (maybe hilarious?) bathroom encounter involving a ghostly hand interrupting an already vulnerable moment. 
If you or someone you know has had a brush with the paranormal and would like to have that story read on the podcast, please email it to anxiousatbedtimepodcast@gmail.com

May 7, 2026

33 min

This week on Anxious At Bedtime, we enter the lawless dimension known only as...Florida. 
First, we dive into the unbelievable story of a Florida man who vanished only to return claiming a dolphin named Geral kidnapped him and forced him to help build a hidden underground city beneath the ocean. 
Then somehow things get even weirder as we investigate Coral Castle, the bizarre monument built by Edward Leedskalnin, a tiny man who somehow moved multi-ton stones completely aloe while claiming he knew the same secrets used to build the pyramids. 
Anti-gravity? Ancient knowledge? Kidnapper dolphins? Just another Thursday in Florida. 
Grab your tinfoil hats and emotional support alligators because tonight we're discussing the absolutely bizarre.
If you or someone you know has had a brush with the paranormal and would like to have that story read on the podcast, please email it to anxiousatbedtimepodcast@gmail.com

Apr 9, 2026

26 min

In the very first Ask Cash episode, nothing is off limits. Are you planning a proposal? A demon summoning? Adopting a new pet? Join us as Cash weighs in on it all, in his own way.
 
Expect honesty, chaos, unexpected wisdom, and at least one moment where we both question why we thought this was a good idea. 
 
It's funny. It's unfiltered. It's slightly concerning. And it's officially the start of Ask Cash. We're probably fine.
 
If you or someone you know has had a brush with the paranormal and would like to have that story read on the podcast, please email it to anxiousatbedtimepodcast@gmail.com

Mar 26, 2026

52 min

What happens after an encounter like that?
In the final part of our Betty and Barney Hill series, we follow the story beyond the night on the road and into the years that came after.
As the Hills tried to move forward, new questions began to take shape. Strange illnesses. Lingering fear. Additional sightings that made it harder and harder to dismiss what they experienced. 
We explore the physical and emotional toll the encounter may have taken, including Barney's declining health and death, and the life Betty continued to live in the shadow of that night. 
We also take a closer look at Betty's now famous star map, the growing attention surrounding their story, and how their private experience became one of the most widely known and debated abduction cases in history. 
Because for the Hills, the story didn't end when they got home. And it didn't end when the memories came back. In many ways, it never ended at all. 
If you or someone you know has had a brush with the paranormal and would like to have that story read on the podcast, please email it to anxiousatbedtimepodcast@gmail.com. 

Mar 12, 2026

56 min

In Part 2 of our Betty and Barney Hill series, we dive into the hypnosis sessions that uncovered the missing hours from that strange night in 1961. From the dinner party where the Hills first shared their story to the investigators who began asking questions, this is the chapter where they mystery deepens and the details of the encounter finally begin to emerge. 
 
If you or someone you know has had a brush with the paranormal and would like to have that story read on the pod, please email to anxiousatbedtimepodcast@gmail.com

Feb 25, 2026

40 min

We're back. 
After some time away, we're returning to the microphones with one of the most famous and unsettling stories in paranormal history. But before the lights in the sky, before the missing time, and before the hypnosis, there were just two people. 
Betty and Barney Hill.
In part 1 of this two parter, we're going back to the beginning. We explore who Betty and Barney were, how they met, and the romantic road trip that would unknowingly cement them in paranormal history forever.  
 
If you or someone you know has had a brush with the paranormal and would like to have that story read on the podcast, please email it to anxiousatbedtimepodcast@gmail.com

Oct 30, 2025

40 min

This Halloween, we're diving deep into one of the world's eeriest legends, black-eyed children. From chilling 1980s sightings to theories linking the phenomenon to tragic murders of the 1960s, these pale, black-eyed visitors have haunted the woods and internet forums alike for decades.
Join Monica and Cash as they unravel real reports, folklore roots, and paranormal theories behind this haunting mystery. Why do so many witnesses describe the same thing? And why do the stories always begin with a knock at the door?
It's our Halloween special, and yes, we're in costume for this one! You can watch the full video episode on YouTube to see our spooky fits and all the eerie expressions that didn't make it into the audio version. 
YouTube version here:
https://youtu.be/4m_GjUftczU?si=BZjiIbPxxeqbkCoQ
If you or someone you know has had a brush with the paranormal and would like to have that story read on the podcast, please email it to anxiousatbedtimepodcast@gmail.com

Oct 24, 2025

59 min

This Halloween season, we're tucking you in with true tales that'll make you sleep with one eye open. From a ghost that steals cabled and remotes to a mimic pretending to be someone's mom, these stories are the perfect mix of eerie, intimate, and unexplainable. 
You'll hear from Nova, one of the original co-creators, about the night she saw a woman drenched in blood, and a listener whose wife somehow knew what happened in his recurring nightmares, but won't say how. Plus, a husband's chilling encounter on a dark rural road that might not have been entirely human and a ghost that seemingly enjoys a good rocking chair. 
So grab a blanket and settle in, it's our October Listener Story special. 
If you or someone you know has had a brush with the paranormal and would like to have that story read on the podcast, please email it to anxiousatbedtimepodcast@gmail.com

Oct 16, 2025

1hr 50 sec

This week, Monica and Cash tumble down the haunted rabbit hole of online listings for cursed and possessed objects, but things get weird fast. One listing vanished right in the middle of recording. One bear named Fanny just wants to play video games. A clown doll refuses to reveal the spirit inside it. And one mysterious doll has Monica eerily close to clicking "Buy Now."
 
Join us as we explore the scary, the absurd, and the possibly possessed corners of the internet, where every "pre-loved" item might just love you back a little too much. 
 
If you or someone you know has had a brush with the paranormal and would like to have that story read on the podcast, please email it to anxiousatbedtimepodcast@gmail.com

Oct 9, 2025

36 min

This week, we take you to one of Idaho's most haunted historic sites, Stricker Ranch. Once a lonely stop on the Oregon Trail and now home to more than just memories. Armed with our mics, curiosity, and the Ghost Tube app, we revisit our past ghost hunts at the ranch. What started as a calm history chat turned into something else entirely... Let's just say, by the end, we didn't end the episode, the ghosts did. And Monica almost peed her pants. 
 
If you or someone you know has had a brush with the paranormal and would like to have that story read on the podcast, please email it to anxiousatbedtimepodcast@gmail.com

Copyright 2024 All rights reserved.

Podcast Powered By Podbean

Version: 20241125